Playback speed
×
Share post
Share post at current time
0:00
/
0:00
Transcript

Turn Your Substack Buttons Into Non-Sucky Click Magnets (In Just 5 Seconds!)

Your buttons deserve more than a generic “Subscribe" (and to make more money)

2025 is here…

And this year, you’ll see me do my online writing business like you’ve never seen before…

Because 2025 marks the beginning of a new era of online writing and marketing

And I’m so excited.

We are ALL here to be noticed. Period.

So, if this is the year you plan to take control of your time, income, and freedom with the online writing business of your dreams…

Then join me and more than 10,000 engaged and like-minded writers, creators, entrepreneurs, and friends.

Here’s what’s in for you:

  • Q&As with masterminds, such as Walter Rhein

  • Live Workshops with superstars, such as Ayodeji

  • Substack Bootcamp and Substack Course

  • NEW! VIP Member Program to make you a bestseller in 2025

  • Community access with 300+ members

  • … you name it

Oh, and did I mention you’ll get for FREE:

I want to make 2025 my BEST year!


Call-to-action (CTA) buttons are everywhere on Substack.

Yet, they’re often overlooked— a huge missed opportunity because you can dramatically improve them in less than five seconds (yes, you read that right!).

Why CTA Buttons Are So Important

CTA buttons on Substack aren’t just functional—they’re powerful tools to guide your readers. Whether subscribing, upgrading, or sharing your content, buttons bridge interest and action.

The words you put on those buttons? They have a massive impact on the outcome. These aren’t just words. They’re statements of value, as we say in marketing. They tell your busy readers:

“This is worth your time.”

Every time someone clicks, they say:

“Yes, I want this!”

Gwen Stefani Singing GIF by The Voice

That’s why your buttons deserve more than a generic “Subscribe.”

Love it! Give me more


Quick Fix: Make Your Buttons More Impactful

Sure, adding a button is easy, but is it effective? That’s where marketing strategy comes in.

1. Customize the Text

Generic buttons won’t inspire action. Try these instead:

  • Boring: “Subscribe.”

  • Better: “Get Free Tips Every Friday!”

Here’s how to do it:

  • Highlight the default button text in your Substack editor.

  • Replace it with something catchy and audience-focused.

Examples:

  • “Join 10,000 Smart Writers.”

  • “Free in Your Inbox Every Monday.”

  • “Don’t Miss Out—Subscribe Now.”

Let me become a member and join the Club


2. Promote More Than Subscriptions

Want to promote courses, services, or products? Use custom buttons to drive traffic beyond just subscriptions.

Steps:

  • Add a URL to your store, course, or coaching page.

  • Update the button text to match.

Examples:

  • “Snag Your Seat Now.”

  • “Book a Coaching Session.”


CTAs That Inspire Action

Your CTA buttons aren’t just clicks—they’re decisions. Crafting them well can skyrocket engagement.

Be Clear and Direct

Tell your readers exactly what to do:

  • “Subscribe for Weekly Writing Tips.”

  • “Book a One-on-One Strategy Session.”

  • “Share This Post with a Friend.”

Create Urgency

Use time-sensitive language to trigger action:

  • “Join 10,000 Writers—Today!”

  • “Upgrade Now to Unlock Exclusive Posts.”

Add Personality

Make your CTAs relatable and fun:

  • “Sign Me Up, Kristina!”

  • “Get Smart Tips Every Friday—For Free!”

    Episode 2 Yes GIF by America's Got Talent

YES! Sign me up, Kristina!


Why Button Text Matters

CTA buttons have a psychological impact. A few well-chosen words can make a big difference:

  • Urgency: “Join Now” triggers FOMO.

  • Connection: “Sign Me Up, Kristina!” feels personal.

  • Clarity: “Free Tips Every Friday” sets clear expectations.

Small tweaks can significantly boost click-through rates.

CTA buttons are a simple tool, but when paired with strong content and straightforward design, they become powerful drivers of engagement. Take a few moments to refine your buttons—you’ll see the difference.

Got CTA questions or want to join our challenge?

Drop them in the comments below—I’ll answer every single one.

Or, better, join the challenge by sharing your button texts with me and the community.

Leave a comment

Until next time!
Keep creating, keep growing, and keep thriving,

P.S. Hungry for more?

Here’s how I can help you to make 2025 your BEST year ever!

Ready to level up your writing and monetize your words? Join The Online Writing Club.

I want to become a member today!

SURPRISE: Join as a VIP member and get 1x audit and 4x strategy sessions with me. Our goal: Make you a Substack bestseller with 100+ paid subscribers who LOVE you (and/or crush your goals on Substack!)

It’s only $500, which is one-twelfth of your annual income, and it’s tax-deductible since it’s a coaching program.

See you inside!

I want to become a VIPer!

Notes Prompt of the Day: Some funny storytelling on Notes… join me and share something humorous, too!

Kristina God's Online Writing Club
Substack School
Tutorial videos, live sessions, replays and exclusive bonuses